• Reversing Nearly a Decade of Positive Trends: The Lingering Impact of the Pandemic on Young Adults Who Are Out of School and Out of Work in New York City

    Reversing Nearly a Decade of Positive Trends: The Lingering Impact of the Pandemic on Young Adults Who Are Out of School and Out of Work in New York City

    In New York City, despite a decade-long trend of increasing gains in the labor market and rising educational attainment, the proportion of 16- to 24-year-olds who are both out of school and out of work has skyrocketed since the COVID-19 pandemic. Such a trend reversal further pushes this already vulnerable population toward the fringes of our economy and society. This brief examines the out-of-school, out-of-work population from a variety of socioeconomic and demographic perspectives, identifies programs and policies that seek to address the needs of this population, and includes recommendations to ensure that young adults who are out of school and out of work are put back on track to economic security.

    What Current Data Says about NYC’s Young Adults Who Are Out of School and Out of Work in NYC

    In the years immediately preceding the pandemic, 2018 and 2019, 13.1% of all 16- to 24-year-olds were neither in school nor part of the labor force—the lowest rate since 2010. Post-pandemic, that share has risen to 16%. 

    There are 138,029 young people who are out of school and out of work in New York City. In absolute terms, an additional 25,500 16- to 24-year-olds have joined the out-of-school, out-of-work category in New York City. This increase is especially noteworthy since the overall population of 16– to 24-year-olds has decreased over the same period. In 2021, the out-of-school, out-of-work rate for 18- to 24-year-olds was 20%–slightly higher than the rate in 2005, when JobsFirstNYC was founded to address this crisis.

    Read the Full Report

    Moreover, this negative shift occurs at a critical time in which the upward mobility of young adults who are out of school and out of work (OSOW) depends on attaining a quality education while concurrently developing a rich foundation of relevant skills necessary to successfully engage with today’s job market demands.

    Figure 1. Count and share of NYC’s out-of-school, out-of-work population, 2010–2021


    Source: American Community Survey Public Use Microdata Sample for 2010 to 2021

    Key Findings from the Data Brief

    The data on young adults who are out of school and out of work uncovered key insights about demographics, neighborhoods, education, and the labor market.

    What is the Current Population of Young Adults who are Out of School and Out of Work in NYC?

    • The total number of young adults who are out of school and out of work has increased significantly since the year prior to the pandemic, reversing a decade-long trend. This increase is especially concerning given that the overall population of 16- to 24-year-olds has decreased over the same period.
    • The share of young adults who are out of school and out of work increased across all races and ethnicities during the pandemic. Black and Latino/a/x/Hispanic communities had the largest increases.
    • Continuing pre-pandemic trends, young adults who are out of school and out of work are more likely to come from under-resourced households, especially from Black and Latino/a/x/Hispanic communities.
    • The gap between the male and female out-of-school, out-of-work rates was narrowing pre-pandemic but has since started to widen. Young adults who are out of school and out of work are now more likely to be male.

    Where do young adults who are out of school and out of work live?

    • The neighborhoods with the overall highest share of the out-of-school, out-of-work population are: Brownsville & Ocean Hill (Brooklyn); Hunts Point, Longwood, & Melrose (Bronx); East Harlem and Central Harlem (Manhattan); and Morris Heights, Fordham South & Mount Hope (Bronx).
    • The neighborhoods experiencing the largest increases in the population of young adults who are out of school and out of work since the start of the pandemic are: Astoria & Long Island City (Queens); Hamilton Heights, Manhattanville, & West Harlem (Manhattan); Concourse, Highbridge, & Mount Eden (Bronx); Riverdale, Fieldston & Kingsbridge (Bronx); and Chelsea, Clinton, and Midtown (Manhattan). 
    • Out-of-school, out-of-work rates in every borough have increased since before the pandemic. Manhattan and Queens have experienced the largest increases, where there are also fewer city workforce program sites.

    What is the state of educational access and attainment?

    • High school graduation rates have remained steady throughout the pandemic for all races/ethnicities, and the gap between races/ethnicities is narrowing. High school stop-out rates have also continued on a downward trend citywide and for all racial/ethnic communities.
    • College attendance rates of Black and Latino/a/x/Hispanic young adults have improved over the last decade. 
    • 75% of young adults who are out of school and out of work lack any college education, restricting their opportunities in the job market.
    • Young adult first-time enrollment into City University of New York (CUNY) Associate’s degree programs were the lowest they’d been in a decade in Fall 2020, at 18,250 students, and reduced even further in Fall 2021 to 14,600 students.
    • Young adult retention rates for the Fall 2020 cohort of CUNY Associate’s degree programs across all institutions were 73% for one-semester and 56% for one-year following matriculation. Nearly half of students who began in Fall 2020 were not retained through one year of Associate’s Degree programs.
    • Young adult enrollment into CUNY non-degree programs is higher in 2020 and 2021 compared to a decade prior, though marginally lower than enrollment in 2019, the peak year of the decade.

    What are the trends in the labor market?

    • Young people are primarily employed in retail, restaurants and hotels. The distribution of employees across industries remains largely the same in the wake of the pandemic. Industrial sectors where young adult employment tends to be highest have yet to fully return to their pre-pandemic levels.
    • Young adult wage growth has been slow relative to growth in wages for all workers, and the share of workers in part-time work has increased.
    • The 2021 youth unemployment rate of 10.3% exceeds the unemployment rate for the overall population, which is 6%. For young black workers, unemployment is 31%, while for young Latinx workers, unemployment is 26%.
    • The employment rate for 16- to 24-year-olds has fallen among both full-time and part-time workers, but the decrease is greater among those employed full time. Across the entire population, the pandemic caused the share of full-time workers to fall and the share of part-time workers to rise. Additionally, young workers are increasingly seeking out work in the gig economy.

    Median wages for full-time workers are $28,138 for 16- to 24-year-olds and $57,554 for the entire population. The median wages of youth workers vary less by race and ethnicity relative to the entire population.

    Recommendations to Meet the Economic Needs of Young People

    The following five recommendations are aimed at meeting the challenges described above. These recommendations echo calls made in other JobsFirstNYC publications regarding the need for partnerships, institutional change and systemic changes to ensure that New York City’s young adults and community members can access economic mobility. 

    Recommendations #1 and #2 are from Barriers to Entry: Fewer Out-of-School, Out-of-Work Young Adults, as Warning Signs Emerge, a study examining how young adults aged 18–24 are faring in the New York City labor market.

    #1: Address the warning signs concerning part-time, low-wage work.

    Steady growth in part-time, low-wage jobs creates long-term economic insecurity and uncertainty. New York City needs to invest in and strengthen opportunities for young adults to access good-paying quality jobs, while also building more intentional opportunities for part-time, low-wage workers to connect to training that will put them on a path to economic mobility. This includes longer post-placement services and more opportunities for part-time workers to continue developing their skills. Furthermore, New York State should begin the policy process to build a portable benefits framework to provide the growing number of part-time workers with greater protections and financial security. 

    #2: Support neighborhood partnership development.
    JobsFirstNYC has spearheaded a number of place-based partnerships — localized solutions that respond to the unique needs of communities with high numbers of OSOW young adults. These partnerships include the Lower East Side Employment Network, the Brownsville Hub Cooperative (Brooklyn), YES Bed-Stuy (Brooklyn), Youth WINS (Staten Island), and the Jerome Avenue Revitalization Collaborative (Bronx). 

    Recommendations #3 and #4 are from JobsFirstNYC’s report Equitable Recovery for Young Adults: An Agenda for Young Adult Workforce Development in New York City, which provides a set of citywide policy priorities rooted in the needs of young people, the perspectives of on-the-ground practitioners, and the literature on successful policies and interventions. 

    #3: Prioritize economic mobility and pathways to prosperity for historically marginalized and disproportionately harmed communities.
    New York City’s young adult workforce system stakeholders can make significant, measurable progress toward this recommendation by: encouraging participation in young adult workforce programs; implementing systems change strategies; centering young adults in planning processes; and prioritizing economic mobility and prosperity.

    #4: Create a seamless continuum of integrated services across education and workforce development institutions.

    New York City’s young adult workforce system must ensure that young people can utilize multiple points of entry and experience uninterrupted transitions between programs, systems, and service providers. This can be done by: providing early career exposure; leveraging existing resources for support; integrating wraparound support programs; increasing the availability of bridge programs; reimagining education pathways; and making credentials easily attainable.

    #5: Implement additional policy changes.

    • Expand the Earned Income Tax Credit to 18- to 24-year-old workers.
    • Substantially increase the minimum wage. While the minimum wage in New York City is set to rise incrementally over the next three years, inflation, poverty, and widespread economic instability may continue to leave many young adults in New York City financially insecure.
    • Strengthen wage equity policies for young adult workers by protecting against wage theft and increasing the reach and enforcement of anti-discrimination policies and workplace protections.
    • Increase investment in initiatives that support young men. Given the alarming rise in unemployment rates among young men in New York City, particularly those of color, it is critical to prioritize investment in programs that support this population.

    JobsFirstNYC’s most recent report, 1 in 4 Young Adults in New York City Were Out of School and Out of Work in 2020, relied on limited data from the Current Population Survey due to the impact of COVID-19 and the delay of 2020 ACS data release. This data brief presents updated data from the American Community Survey (ACS), which provides a more complete and reliable picture of the years affected by the pandemic.

    Call to Action

    This data brief demonstrates that in the wake of nearly a decade of gains in connecting young adults to school and work, the COVID-19 pandemic has reversed this trend, with devastating consequences for New York City’s young adults and the communities in which they live. 

    For more insights, explore our updated post.

  • JobsFirstNYC 2020-2021 Annual Report

    JobsFirstNYC 2020-2021 Annual Report

    Last year challenged our North Star to reduce the number of  young people who are out of school and out of work and to improve economic opportunities for them and the communities in which they live. The COVID-19 pandemic continued to impact the lives of young people, hitting those in historically economically challenged communities especially hard, above all by impeding their ability to secure sustainable livelihoods. Indeed, last year, about 184,000 New Yorkers aged 18–24 (almost 27% of this age group) were out of school and out of work, representing an 80% increase from the previous year. This brought us nearly full circle to where we were in 2006, when a similar crisis facing this population provided the impetus for JobsFirstNYC’s creation.

    Against this backdrop, we worked diligently with our partners to address the repercussions of COVID-19 and to ensure that young adults would not be left behind in the city’s economic recovery. We made notable headway in advancing economic opportunities and mobility for young adults and their communities. In particular, we:

    Download Now
    • advanced community solutions to improve place-based economics by launching three place-based partnerships: the Brownsville Hub Cooperative (Brooklyn), the Jerome Avenue Revitalization Collaborative (Bronx), and YES Bed Stuy (Brooklyn). These new partnerships aim to provide resources and services to jobseekers to today’s ever-changing public health dynamics.
    • improved education pathways to upward mobility by further embedding career pathways in the New York City high school system. In this regard, we partnered with the New York City Department of Education to support 500 high schools in providing staff with a postsecondary planning practitioner credential to prepare students to make informed postsecondary choices.
    • advanced workforce equity by building on effective approaches to improve outcomes for workers and employers. In particular, drawing on the successes of our signature Young Adult Sectoral Employment Project, we began designing three citywide sector networks aimed at advancing high-quality skills training, strengthening collective mechanisms for workforce development organizations to negotiate with employers, and increasing employment opportunities and wages for young adults. The first network to be launched was the Green Economy Network.
    • analyzed the challenges and opportunities facing young adults, their communities, and workforce development practitioners by engaging in policy advocacy, research, and learning work. Our efforts centered on elevating the voices of practitioners, defining the challenges of our constituents, and uncovering opportunities for effective solutions.
    • explored ways to integrate diversity, equity, and inclusion into our workspaces. In the wake of the 2021 Insurrection, we called for Americans to stand up for a democracy that gives an equal voice to every American.

    There is a pressing need to act swiftly to reduce the number of 16- to 24-year-olds who are out of school and out of work; to connect these young adults to training, education, and work; to advance them along educational and career pathways; and to provide early exposure to career development throughout the public education system.

    This pandemic has created the perfect storm for leaving another generation of young adults behind. Meeting the challenges of 2022 and beyond will require all of us to lean in and find equitable solutions.

    Sincerely,

    Alan Momeyer, Chairman of the Board,  and Marjorie D. Parker, President and CEO

     

     

    See All Annual Reports

  • We are Better Together

    We are Better Together

    JobsFirstNYC convened stakeholders across its expansive network on February 24, 2022, for its first Partnership Forum of 2022. This forum provided opportunities for learning and sharing amongst training providers, economic development advocates, and young adult workforce practitioners. This Partnership Forum facilitated conversations across multiple JobsFirstNYC solutions areas, sectors, and types of stakeholders working to transform systems supporting young adults and their communities in the pursuit of economic mobility. The previous Partnership Forum was held in November 2020, where partners across all community practice neighborhoods came together to discuss challenges and opportunities presented by COVID-19. This year, JobsFirstNYC seeks to continue convening with the hopes of strengthening the community of practice and resource-sharing across its partnerships.
    1. Highlights from the February 2022 Partnership Forum include: Marissa Martin, Executive Director at The Advocacy Institute, presented an overview of the fundamentals of building advocacy and policy campaigns as well as what to expect from New York state and city policy agencies based on the information that has been shared publicly to date. Marissa also gave some background on the Legislative Campaign Assessment and Tracking Tool (LCATT), which was developed to address challenges in tracking legislative advocacy.
    2. SkyHive showcased its Skills Passport labor analytics platform, which continuously collects and analyzes millions of real-time labor market data points to democratize job information. Sergey Bukharov, Chief Customer Officer at SkyHive, shared their vision for a future where every individual looking for work across any community will possess a Skills Passport that elucidates their skills journeys and seamlessly allows entry into new opportunities. JobsFirstNYC has engaged in a strategic partnership with SkyHive to work with partners to map jobseeker skills, jobs, and training across specific geographic areas and examine employment activities, advance workforce strategy, and increase effectiveness across the system.
    3. Representatives from each of JobsFirstNYC’s partnerships provided highlights on 2021 and 2022 goals:
      1. Bronx Opportunity Network (BON) – Allison Palmer, Associate Executive Director at New Settlement, shared that the partnership exceeded their 2021 new student enrollment goal in spite of community college enrollment issues. In 2022, the BON will be launching a Transfer Pilot to support student transfer from community college to a senior college.
      2. Brownsville Hub Cooperative (BHC) – Roman Jackson, Vice President at JobsFirstNYC, updated partners on the strides that have been made by the steering committee, including the establishment of a physical HUB space in Brownsville, the formalization of a partnership governance structure, and the launch of a community website filled with resources and jobs for community members. The BHC has recently hired network staff and is currently working on developing a launch event, and establishing subcommittees to help advance the partnership’s activities in the year ahead.
      3. Green Economy Network – Jennifer Dillon, Vice President of Workforce Development at The Doe Fund, shared a description of the Network and news of the partnership establishing four working groups led and supported by 37 different nonprofit organizations, city agencies, and employers in 2021 and 2022. The working groups are driving big-picture decision-making as well as progress toward achieving the partnership’s three priority goals. They are co-leading the Network’s efforts to create systems mapping and job search products, as well as advocating for the Network’s recent policy proposals.
      4. Jerome Avenue Revitalization Collaborative (JARC) – Karen-Michelle Mirko Director of Employment and Graduate Services at The HOPE Program, highlighted the partnership’s launch campaign, JARC Week, which took place in February 2021. Looking ahead, the JARC is working towards securing a fiscal sponsor, creating more direct and culturally relevant channels that engage community business owners, and building capacity for partnership operations and for workforce needs in the West Bronx.
      5. Lower East Side Employment Network (LESEN) – Roman Jackson, Vice President at JobsFirstNYC, detailed how LESEN is getting constituents prepared for hospitality jobs of the future. LESEN tackled this challenge in 2021 through the launch of a digital training program for vulnerable jobseekers and job training programs across all sectors.
      6. Transfer to Career Collaborative (T2C) – Amanda Rosenblum, Senior Director of Education Solutions at JobsFirstNYC, described the expansion of the partnership’s model across the public high school system through a partnership with the DOE. T2C’s expansion also includes launching the CDOS Institute for Workforce Practitioners to expand career pathway opportunities in schools.
      7. Youth Empowerment Services Bed Stuy (YBS) – Hanjy Charles, Program Director at CAMBA, shared the success of their Youth Committee’s  2021 strategy to train young adults on job-readiness skills and prepare them to become community leaders. YBS seeks to hire a Youth Engagement Coordinator in 2022 to scale efforts of serving young adults in the Bed Stuy community.
      8. Youth WINS (Workforce Initiative Network of Staten Island – Michael DeVito, Executive Director at NYCID, highlighted the advocacy committee’s recent work, which includes drafting a letter to municipal officials, creating the partnership’s first policy agenda, holding a city council candidate debate, and facilitating a Staten Island Borough President Candidate Forum. Based on significant traction made on the advocacy front, Youth WINS is planning to build a network service hub in 2022 while cultivating relationships with advanced education providers.
    4. Attendees participated in Hot Topic Discussions that reflected the most pressing issues partners are currently facing in their work. Breakout room groups responded to the questions: “What is one strategy, tool, or best practice you’ve used to address this topic?” and “What is one question or challenge you still have about this topic?”. Most pertinent hot topics were: 
      1. Re-engaging with young people and/or community members,
      2. Building relationships with employers,
      3. Best/proven practices for collaborating around fundraising, gathering community resources, and other opportunities,
      4. Strategies for going “back-to-normal” post-COVID, and
      5. Stakeholder engagement within a partnership.
    5. JobsFirstNYC is launching a Policy Committee and has shared an open call for members of each partnership to join. The goal of this committee is to identify and promote opportunities to shape public perception and raise awareness of strategies that enhance systems supporting out-of-school, out-of-work young adults in New York City. Nominations are still open to join the Policy Committee, via the following link: JobsFirstNYC’s Policy Committee Application.
    JobsFirstNYC invites all partners to join us at the next Partnership Forum taking place in October 2022. As we continue to observe how the new administrations at the city, state, and federal levels will support workforce development and out of school, out of work young adults. The next forum will feature a NYATEP (New York Association for Training and Employment Professionals) presentation on the recent state budget that was approved and provide key insights on issues they continue to advocate for. Partners will also have the opportunity to build on the pertinent issues discussed at the February event and hear from partners about the best practices to advance the work. We look forward to another morning of lively conversation with our partners!

  • President Biden Signs $1.2 Trillion Infrastructure Bill

    President Biden Signs $1.2 Trillion Infrastructure Bill

    On November 15, 2021, President Joe Biden signed a $1.2 trillion infrastructure bill into law. This historic legislation will fund much-needed upgrades to America’s physical infrastructure and create an estimated two million jobs per year for the next decade.  More specifically, the bill pledges to spend:
    • $1 billion for occupation-specific training through the Departments of Energy and Transportation
    • $65 billion to increase broadband Internet access
    • $110 billion for roads and bridges
    • $66 billion for passenger and freight rail improvements
    • $65 billion to modernize the power grid
    • $55 billion on water and wastewater infrastructure
    • $47 billion for cybersecurity and to create a climate change Resilience Fund
    • $39 billion on public transit, including accessibility upgrades
    • $25 billion for upgrades and expansion at airports
    • $21 billion for environmental cleanup
    • $17 billion for ports, including expanding port infrastructure
    • $7.5 billion to create electric vehicle charging stations
    • $7.5 billion to purchase electric and hybrid buses
    These investments are important not just because they will create jobs, but because they will allow many people to live healthier, safer lives, and will begin to build up our nation’s resilience in the face of climate change. Our country’s aging infrastructure has needed concentrated investment for years, if not decades. However, the infrastructure bill only represents part of Biden’s vision for America’s response to the pandemic-induced recession and the threat of climate change. For the infrastructure bill to meet its ambitious goals, we will need an average of two million skilled, job-ready workers every year for the next ten years. In order to meet that need, we must pass the $1.75 trillion Build Back Better (BBB) budget reconciliation bill, which invests in proven programs that create a trained workforce, including Pell grants, apprenticeships, subsidized jobs, and access to wraparound services, such as affordable childcare. The BBB bill also includes programs explicitly targeted toward young adults, ensuring that those most impacted by the recession are a key part of the recovery. While the American Rescue Plan provided some funding through their Good Jobs Challenge, this is not enough to meet our current need, nor will it address the potential shortage of skilled labor when the infrastructure bill is signed into law. The infrastructure bill was passed as part of a promise to pass the BBB within the month. Democrats are hoping to pass the bill by Thanksgiving, but have had past attempts delayed by conservative Democrats. It is imperative that the workforce development field join together to pressure our elected officials to pass the budget reconciliation bill as quickly as possible, and without stripping any more important provisions. Passage of the BBB is a multi-generational investment that will transform the lives of working class Americans for decades to come.
  • Making Rezoning Work

    Making Rezoning Work

    As New York City grapples with a protracted economic crisis brought on by COVID-19, city leaders will be searching for opportunities to help spark a lasting economic rebound and regain many of the nearly 500,000 jobs lost since March 2020. One option is to use zoning tools to encourage economic development, attracting private investment at a time when public funding is extremely limited and helping to revive the city’s battered economy. But to earn the trust of communities that have been hit hardest by the pandemic—and ensure that new development benefits the New Yorkers most in need of economic opportunities—New York City will need to develop a bold new vision for building workforce development infrastructure at the neighborhood level. Since 2016, communities across New York City, from East New York to Inwood, have undergone large-scale residential rezoning. Designed to encourage the construction of affordable housing, neighborhood rezoning plans have nonetheless sparked understandable fears that new development enabled by land-use changes will lead to gentrification and displacement. The de Blasio administration has responded to these concerns by tying housing protections and other investments to neighborhood rezoning plans. However, thus far, the rezoning plans have lacked investment and accountability around local workforce development. The need for these investments is clear: In the six neighborhoods which have already been rezoned, median household income is nearly $17,000 below the city average. More than a year into the COVID-19 pandemic, the estimated unemployment rate in East Harlem is upward of 20 percent and nearly 30 percent along Jerome Avenue in the Bronx. For many residents of these neighborhoods—and many others throughout the city—obtaining a living-wage job in an eventual economic recovery is made harder without access to quality workforce development services. While recent rezoning plans have included numerous commitments—from housing protections for current renters to new community spaces and playgrounds—workforce investments have been minimal. According to its commitment trackers, the city budgeted just $462,250 for job training initiatives focused on just two of the six residential neighborhoods approved for rezoning since 2016. Just $312,500 had been spent on new job training programs as of June 2021. A more deliberate approach is needed: one that provides communities with a blueprint for establishing and strengthening neighborhood-level workforce networks, taps private sector dollars to invest in meeting workforce needs, builds the capacity of training providers to serve more residents, scales up the most effective workforce programs from across the city, and incentivizes partnership and collaboration. This report examines the current role of workforce investments in the city’s recent and ongoing neighborhood rezoning plans and charts a path for city policymakers, workforce practitioners, philanthropic leaders, and local community-based organizations and business leaders to support a new model for place-based workforce investment that can help expand economic opportunity in the communities that need it most. This report—a joint effort between the Center for an Urban Future and JobsFirstNYC—demonstrates the need to integrate a comprehensive workforce development strategy into future rezonings and offers a blueprint for how to do so. Informed by more than 50 interviews with workforce development practitioners, community leaders, city officials, nonprofit executives, and economic development experts—as well as analysis of data on economic and workforce conditions, city reports, budget documents, and other information—the report identifies effective models for place-based workforce development in and outside New York, examines obstacles to integrating workforce development investments into rezoning plans, and lays out a set of practical and actionable recommendations to integrate community-focused skills-building and workforce development investments into rezoning efforts—now and in the future. The report outlines seven recommendations that the next mayor should enable in order to make coordinated workforce investments a top priority.
    • Launch a comprehensive neighborhood-based workforce development strategy to build and strengthen local hiring and training networks and coordinate investments across agencies.
    • Develop a local workforce network in every neighborhood with a poverty or unemployment rate higher than the city average—whether or not a rezoning is imminent.
    • Establish citywide linkage fees for developers of market-rate commercial, residential, and industrial space,  and use the proceeds to create an education and training fund for neighborhoods undergoing rezoning.
    • Require developers and contractors with city contracts to partner with local workforce networks and pass community hiring legislation at the state level
    • Leverage public funding to incentivize long-term partnerships among community-based organizations and workforce development providers.
    • Create a community toolkit for designing and planning workforce investments as part of any future zoning reform.
    • Set a goal of launching 5,000 new apprentices by 2025.
    Download the Full Report      
  • Equitable Recovery for Young Adults: An Agenda for Young Adult Workforce Development in New York City

    Equitable Recovery for Young Adults: An Agenda for Young Adult Workforce Development in New York City

    Our latest report, Equitable Recovery for Young Adults: An Agenda for Young Adult Workforce Development in New York City provides a set of citywide policy priorities rooted in the real needs of young people, the perspectives of on-the-ground practitioners, and the literature on successful policies and interventions. It details the changes needed to quickly connect 18- to 24-year-olds to employment now and to effectively prepare them for the future of work in a rapidly shifting, increasingly virtual economy. It builds on JobsFirstNYC’s comprehensive, system-level view of the City’s young adult workforce ecosystem. Finally, it proposes an actionable, realistic, and timebound framework to foster citywide systems change in the young adult workforce development field.
    Download the Executive Summary
    New York City needs to act swiftly to reduce the number of 18- to 24-year-olds who are out of school and out-of-work; to connect these young adults to training, education, and work opportunities; and to advance them along educational and career pathways. To this end, our report outlines six recommendations for the city that were informed by a diverse coalition of young adult workforce development and education stakeholders and 18- to 24-year-olds. To enact these recommendations, JobsFirstNYC calls for a $770 million increase in annual investment by New York City.
    1. Collaboration: Encourage and reward collaboration across young adult workforce programs and providers.
    2. Focus on Equity: Prioritize economic mobility and pathways to prosperity for historically under-resourced and disproportionately harmed communities.
    3. Employer Partnerships: Significantly expand partnerships with employers and industry groups to create employment and career pathway opportunities.
    4. Continuum of Services: Create a seamless continuum of integrated services across education and youth workforce development institutions.
    5. Youth-Centered Strategies: Design youth-informed solutions that center young adults, their experiences, and goals.
    6. Capacity Building: Build the capacity of workforce providers to deliver high-quality, culturally competent, market-aligned services to young adults.
    This proposed funding would support:
    • $100 million for bridge programming
    • $150 million for sectoral training
    • $357 million for subsidized jobs
    • $105 million for high school degree attainment and career preparation
    • $58 million for capacity building and system enhancements
    Equitable Recovery for Young Adults
    Download the Full Report
    The COVID-19 pandemic has revealed and exacerbated many inequities, from health outcomes to economic outcomes. The pandemic has also accelerated the future of work, namely increased remote work and the displacement of workers by automation. Research has shown that 18- to 24-year-old workers in New York City are 35% more likely to have lost work than all other workers since the pandemic began and that young adults and people of color were disproportionately employed in the city’s hardest-hit industries. The latest data from labor market analytics firm Chmura shows that 1 in 4 18- to 24-year-olds were out of school and out of work in 2020, totaling over 183,000 individuals. JobsFirstNYC and young adult service providers across New York City are more committed now than ever to ensuring that all young adults, and especially those who are out of school and out of work, have the resources, skills, and opportunities they need and deserve to find success in work and in life.  
  • Pandemic Spurred Major Jump in Out of School, Out of Work Young Adults in New York City: Report

    Pandemic Spurred Major Jump in Out of School, Out of Work Young Adults in New York City: Report

    The number of young adults who are both out of school and unemployed surged during the pandemic after declining for much of the past decade, a new report from the workforce development organization JobsFirstNYC confirmed. The analysis, commissioned by JobsFirstNYC and conducted by the analytics firm Chmura, crunched data from the Census Bureau’s Community Population Survey to show 27% of 18-to-24 year-olds, or roughly 184,000 young-adult New Yorkers, were out of school and out of work (OSOW) in 2020. The figure represents an 80% increase in OSOW youth from the year prior and the highest it’s been at least since 2010. The new analysis, released this week, adds weight to an estimate published by the city’s Disconnected Youth Task Force in January, which found one in four 16-to-24 year-olds were likely OSOW, along with racial and geographic disparities in the OSOW youth population. The JobsFirstNYC study also revealed new information about the disproportionate increase in women who were unenrolled and unemployed during the first year of the pandemic. “2020 was a devastating year for young adult New Yorkers in terms of jobs lost and education deferred, resulting in an alarming increase in the rate and number of 18- to 24-year-olds out of school and out of work to 27%,” wrote Marjorie Parker, president and CEO of JobsFirstNYC, in an email to Gotham Gazette. “What that meant last year was an urgent need to acquire new skills and improve existing ones to compete in a fast-changing labor market. That truth will persist in the future,” she wrote. JobsFirstNYC and other workforce development providers have pushed the city for more funding to address the problem and to undertake concerted efforts to understand the shifting needs of the labor force. That could include skills mapping studies to identify strengths and gaps in local labor markets and the requirements of available jobs. Advocates have also emphasized the importance of bridge programs that help jobseekers attain the skills or training they need to advance or change careers as the job market changes. JobsFirstNYC plans to release a policy paper this fall with “actionable” recommendations for the current and next mayor, as city government faces massive turnover in January. The OSOW rate typically fluctuates seasonally, ticking up during the summer months when most school is out of session and dropping again in the fall when classes resume. The number peaked in June 2020 reflecting the impacts of the worst of the pandemic — likely a decade high — at 331,000, a staggering 41% of residents aged 18 to 24, according to the report. During that time, the early summer peak coincided with a city and national economy taking its first steps back after the pandemic had forced businesses to close and most public life to grind to a halt. The new study found that New Yorkers aged 18 and 19 were far more likely to postpone college in 2020, causing the summer’s high rates to extend into August. Seventy-six percent of that age group were OSOW in August 2020, compared to rates averaging in the mid-to-lower 40 percentages during the same month over the previous four years (2016-2019). Overall, the rate of out-of-school 18-to-24 year-olds grew twelve points to 59% from 2019 to 2020. Youth “disconnection,” as it is sometimes called, disproportionately impacted Latino communities, which accounted for 39% of the OSOW population, the report found, despite making up just 30% of the city’s young adult population. White New Yorkers, on the other hand, were underrepresented in the figures, comprising 28% of the city population, but only 21% of out of school and out of work young adults. The study also revealed gender inequities in the OSOW boom of 2020. Between 2019 and 2020, the number of young OSOW women rose by 60%, while their male counterparts grew by 37%. The figure reflects the larger number of women leaving or being pushed out of the workforce during the pandemic when businesses and schools shuttered, many jobs disappeared or moved online, and child care needs soared. Total unemployment among 18-to-24-year-olds of any gender doubled over the same period of time — from 4% to 8%, or 54,000 young adults. But a much larger number is (and has historically been) the number of New Yorkers in that age group who are considered outside the labor force altogether, because they are not actively seeking employment, with jobseekers the denominator used for unemployment tallies. That number reached 134,000 in 2020, a six point increase from 2019. The Bronx had the highest levels of OSOW youth by a significant margin, a point also made in the Disconnected Youth Task Force’s January report, which came far later than a deadline set in city law. The new data showed 37% of 18-to-24 year-olds in the Bronx were OSOW, compared with between 23% and 25% in the other boroughs. The Community Population Survey does not contain neighborhood-level data, but JobsFirstNYC noted the Census Bureau plans to release more granular information later this year. Previous studies have shown the South Bronx and East New York, Brooklyn to be the hardest hit, with the Mott Haven-Hunts Point section of the Bronx home to the most out of school out of work young adults.
    *** by Ethan Geringer-Sameth, reporter, Gotham Gazette
  • Young People Need and Deserve Additional Support to Build Their Skills

    Young People Need and Deserve Additional Support to Build Their Skills

    During his address to Congress last Wednesday, President Biden unveiled an impressive American Families Plan aimed at helping marginalized American families get back on their feet after years of economic struggle, which has been further exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. This sweeping plan includes a request for a more than $290 billion investment for higher education. According to the plan, “American workers need and deserve additional support to build their skills, increase their earnings, remain competitive, and share in the benefits of the new economy.”  At JobsFirstNYC, we applaud this bold effort to recognize the value that community colleges provide to millions of less fortunate Americans. Underfunded community colleges have led to lower retention and graduation rates. In order for there to be equitable recovery across the country – including in New York City – there needs to be a major push toward quality education at all levels and toward dynamic skills training that is accessible to everyone. The American Families Plan would do just that, rectifying America’s overpriced and broken postsecondary education system which has historically put opportunities for economic advancement out of the reach of those who need it the most.  The most notable part of the plan is that all American’s who want to pursue a college degree, will be provided with two years of free tuition at community colleges. This $109 billion investment has the potential to increase enrollment in four-year colleges over the long term because it would allow many young people to get a jumpstart on their education right out of high school but without having to take on suffocating debt. For New Yorkers, free community college would help clear a direct pathway from high school to postsecondary education at any of the seven CUNY Community College campuses across the city’s five boroughs.  At JobsFirstNYC, we have collaborated with CUNY to develop innovative career pathways to higher education through partnerships such as the Transfer 2 Career Collaborative, Youth WINS, Bronx Opportunity Network and YES Bed Stuy to support students from low-income families. These partnerships have proven that community colleges not only provide a valuable college education, but also connect students to the necessary skills training to prepare them for successful careers. Some other highlights from the plan include investments to:
    • Keep students on track to graduate: A record $62 billion has been earmarked for investments in effective strategies that help keep college students on track to graduate and achieve their degree. This would be a huge win for students who struggle to stay in school because of financial constraints, family obligations, and having to juggle multiple low-paying jobs. This portion of the plan would be further supported by a variety of wraparound services ranging from childcare to faculty and peer mentoring.
    • Support underfunded institutions primarily serving Black Indigenous and other people of color: Biden’s plan acknowledges the huge disparity in funding that has plagued colleges and universities that serve mostly minority students. Under this plan, Historically Black Colleges and Universities, Tribal Colleges and Universities, and institutions such as Hispanic, Asian American, Native American Pacific Islander, and other minority-serving institutions stand to receive $46 billion. In addition, families that make under $125,000 would receive two additional years of tuition subsidies.
    • Expand Federal Pell Grant: The plan includes an $80 billion commitment to expand the Pell Grants, doubling the current maximum grant award. As noted in the plan, “Among students of color, nearly 60 percent of Black, half of American Indian or Alaska Native, almost half of Latino, and over one-third of Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students rely on Pell Grants to pay for college.”
    We celebrate the president’s announcement of the American Families Plan and the promise it holds for securing much-needed education reform and funding. Together with our partners, we are going to amplify our calls for Congress to enact this legislation on behalf of young people in America.  
  • JobsFirstNYC Strongly Endorses the American Jobs Plan

    JobsFirstNYC Strongly Endorses the American Jobs Plan

    On Wednesday, March 31, 2021, President Biden unveiled his American Jobs Plan, a $2 trillion investment in physical and social infrastructure improvements, including a $100 billion investment in workforce development. The ambitious, historic plan prioritizes investments in the green economy and in racial equity initiatives, while encouraging unionization and collective bargaining to ensure that the jobs created are good quality jobs. It will be funded through the Made in America Tax Plan, which will close corporate tax loopholes and require that infrastructure improvements are made using goods manufactured in the United States and shipped on U.S.-flagged vessels. JobsFirstNYC strongly endorses the American Jobs Plan, which places such a high priority on proven job training programs, as well as on creating living wage jobs in safe conditions. A summary of the plan can be found at the end of this piece. The plan echoes many of the policy priorities of JobsFirstNYC, including the emphasis on subsidized jobs and ensuring workforce investments lead to high-quality, living wage jobs. The focus on climate change and resiliency ties to the work of our Green Economy Network, the investment in community-based small business incubators mirrors the work of the Brownsville Hub Cooperative, and the Transfer 2 Career Collaborative has worked on integrating career pathway programming into transfer high schools. These are strategies that we know work to move the needle for young adults and the communities where they live, and we’re excited by the possibility of having them scaled nationally with intentional federal funding. The American Jobs Plan also ties directly to two out of three JobsFirstNYC’s strategies to achieve racial and economic justice:
    1. Invest in the Financial Stability of Workers in their Communities: To improve the financial stability of low-income workers, we believe the issues of stagnant wages and financial instability needs greater attention with a focus on the role that employers can play in providing good jobs that produce better outcomes for them and their workers.
    2. Invest in Community Economics: To ensure the economic well-being of these communities, investments must be made in local human service institutions to build partnerships to leverage resources that will scale on-the-ground capacity.
    The strategy that is missing, however, is a key one for JobsFirstNYC: Invest in the Economic Security of Young Adults. Young adult development and economic advancement are critical to changing the long-term economic mobility of disenfranchised communities. Since the Great Recession, despite increases in employment, almost all gains for 18- to 24-year-olds have been in part-time, lower-wage, and direct-service jobs, leaving most young adults underemployed. While overall the American Jobs Plan is a historic investment in workforce development and reflective of policies we know to be effective, it is missing a more explicit commitment to serving young adults who are out of school and out of work, with most funding for young people going to high schools and colleges, or limited to justice-involved youth. Currently, Measure of America estimates that nine million young adults are not in school or working. In mid 2020, the Aspen Institute estimated that as of May 2020 in New York City there were between 259,000 and 324,000 out of school, out of work young adults.  Fortunately, there is a lot of flexibility around how local and state governments can interpret the plan’s policies. Before and when the plan is signed into law, we must:
    • Work closely with city and state representatives to ensure that out of school, out of work young adults are included as a priority population; 
    • Carve out space for young adults in the Civilian Climate Corps, creating a platform and a means for them to be part of addressing local issues and building the future for their own communities;
    • Ensure that the organizations effectively serving young adults receive the appropriate funding to train and connect their participants to newly created jobs;
    • Make certain that the necessary local infrastructure, such as local hiring agreements, strong employer partnerships, and supported local businesses are in place so that people from skills training programs have easy access to the jobs being created through this plan; and
    • Build strong place-based and sector-based partnerships that are able to prepare a solid talent pipeline for these new job opportunities.
    Some important highlights of the plan include investments in the following areas, which could create or save up to 15 million jobs nationally:
    1. Workforce Development:
      • Cross-sector partnerships: $40 billion for sector-based training that emphasizes cross-sector partnerships and wraparound services, similar to JobsFirstNYC’s Young Adult Sectoral Employment Project;
      • Justice-involved youth: $12 billion for violence prevention as well as skills-based training and subsidized jobs for the formerly incarcerated and justice-involved youth; and
      • Pre-apprenticeship and apprenticeship: $48 billion to create one to two million pre-apprenticeship and apprenticeship slots, integrate career pathway programming in middle and high schools, expand community college partnerships, and strengthen labor law enforcement agencies.
    2. Physical Infrastructure Improvements:
      • Climate change resiliency: $50 billion in resiliency projects to mitigate the impact of climate change on vulnerable communities;
      • Public housing: $40 billion for public housing repairs;
      • Civilian Climate Corps: $10 billion for the Civilian Climate Corps;
      • Transit improvements: Public transit upgrades; and
      • Lead pipes: Replacement of all lead pipes.
    3. Social Infrastructure Improvements:
      • Broadband access: $100 billion to broadband access, prioritizing support for broadband operated by government, nonprofits, or cooperatives, and including a plan for affordability;
      • Homecare access: $400 billion to increase access to home care, as well as to improve the pay of home care workers;
      • Job labs in public schools: $100 billion for upgrades to public schools to create labs for “jobs of the future”;
      • Postsecondary education: $12 billion to community colleges; and
      • Small business incubators: $31 billion for community-based small business incubators and innovation hubs.
    President Biden’s proposed plan is just a beginning. It still must make its way through the legislative process before being signed into law, and even then the roll out may be slow. While we monitor and work to influence its progress, we must continue to press forward with the work on the ground, and with our local and state governments, to ensure that we are prepared for out of school, out of work young adults and the communities where they live to benefit from this historic investment.
  • ‘Shameful’: No Sign of City’s Long Overdue Plan for 250,000-Plus Disconnected Youth

    ‘Shameful’: No Sign of City’s Long Overdue Plan for 250,000-Plus Disconnected Youth

    While unemployment booms and New York City faces its worst economy in decades, the fate of the city’s disconnected youth — people aged 16 to 24 who are both out of work and out of school — is getting a shrug from city government. The city’s Disconnected Youth Task Force, created by the City Council and Mayor Bill de Blasio to examine the factors that inhibit employment and school enrollment among this group numbering in the hundreds of thousands, is more than two years late to submit its first report, a requirement of the 2017 legislation that created it. Now it appears as though the de Blasio administration is waylaying the report again after a draft circulated among members this summer. Practitioners in the field say the endless delays point to a lack of commitment from both sides of City Hall to address young people falling through the cracks, with one task force member calling the hold-up “shameful.” “It is shameful that it’s not out yet, given the crisis, given that it’s been almost two years,” said Marjorie Parker, head of JobsFirstNYC and a member of the task force, in a phone interview with Gotham Gazette. “They shouldn’t sit on this thing for two years. I know covid happened but other people have done reports in shorter periods of time than that.” The urgency has only increased during the pandemic, during which time youth unemployment increased sevenfold — reaching 35% in June — and gun violence has soared. (While the mayor regularly cites a confluence of factors, including rising unemployment, to explaining the uptick in shootings, there is no definitive causation.) The task force, set up through legislation passed and signed in April 2017, has been plagued by delays from the start. The bill, sponsored by City Council Member Mathieu Eugene, then chair of the Council’s youth services committee, under former Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito, required the Mayor and the Speaker to appoint its members within 30 days. Its mandate was to explore barriers and policy solutions to youth employment and education gaps and produce a report with recommendations by March 1, 2018. Close to two years later, in February 2019, de Blasio only announced the launch of the task force under the leadership of Deputy Mayor J. Phillip Thompson, with 20 appointees, five fewer than the law established and mostly representing city agencies with a handful of nonprofit partners. The report is still lost in the offing. “It is critical that we provide young people the tools they need to thrive in our city,” de Blasio said in a statement the day of the launch. “This taskforce will build our work already underway in this area and will help better identify and meet these needs. I look forward to seeing what recommendations they develop.” Thompson said the administration was already taking steps to address the vulnerable population at hand but that he would work with the task force members “to develop a better coordinated strategy among programs servicing youth citywide.” At the time the task force bill was first heard in City Council committee, in November 2016, an estimated 172,000 New York City residents aged 18 to 24 were out of school and out of work, close to a fifth of that age group citywide, according to a report prepared by Council staff. Two-thirds of that population did not have a high school diploma. In 2019, pre-pandemic, there were 129,000 disconnected 16- to 24-year-olds, according to the Aspen Institute, a global nonprofit focused on equality. It is not clear what factors contributed to the drop in disconnected youth by 2019. The latest estimates from Aspen Institute in July indicate the number of out-of-school-and-work young people more than doubled in the first months of the covid crisis in New York, falling anywhere between 259,000 and 324,000 16- to 24-year-olds, or 27% to 34% of that population in the city. Figures available from November on the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics website place the nationwide number of unemployed and not-enrolled 16- to 24-year-olds at roughly 5 million. That number is significantly lower than what was reported in a Pew Research Center study from June, citing Bureau of Labor Statistics data, which revealed that nationwide 28% of youth ages 16 to 24, 10.3 million people, were out of work and school. The rate more than doubled between February and June, from 12%, as the COVID-19 pandemic took hold and forced economic shutdowns across the country. According to Richard Fry, a co-author the Pew study, “there is some seasonality to enrollment, both at high school and college.” The fall months, when many students are back in school, account for the precipitous drop between June and November, he told Gotham Gazette. In addition to representatives from agencies like the New York City Department of Youth and Community Development and the Department of Education, the mayor was given six appointees on the Disconnected Youth Task Force and the Council speaker was given five. The 2019 press release of the launch lists the members but not who appointed them and the speaker’s office, now under Speaker Corey Johnson, did not clarify how many were selected by the Council. In response to Gotham Gazette inquiries about the Council’s role in the task force, a spokesperson said that when the body creates a task force through legislation, the Council makes appointments as required by the law, but the administration is “in charge.” “As you know covid changed many dynamics in the city,” wrote Jose Bayona, a mayoral spokesperson, in October, who at the time said an update would be available at the end of November. On November 23, Bayona told Gotham Gazette, “it seems like we are releasing the report in the first week of December.” The report has not materialized as of December 17 and representatives for the mayor, Council Speaker Corey Johnson, and Council Member Eugene have not been able to provide updates since. “Our office will provide an update as soon as possible,” said Adam Ullian, a spokesperson for  Eugene, a Brooklyn Democrat who is currently running for borough president. Unlike past recessions, the coronavirus pandemic has had a unique impact on young people, spurring unemployment while also driving down community college enrollment, which has historically risen during economic downturns. According to new figures released by the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center and reported by The 74, undergraduate college enrollment dropped 29% in fall 2020 among low-income high school graduates nationwide, close to double the rate among students from high-income schools. While enrollment fell among all students, the most acute decline was among Native American students, followed by Black students, both of which continued downward trends from last fall. The Clearinghouse figures show that undergraduate enrollment at Historically Black Colleges and Universities declined more sharply than the national average. At the same time, in New York City, youth unemployment has skyrocketed during the pandemic. In June, City Comptroller Scott Stringer released a report showing the unemployment rate among 16- to 24-year olds had risen to a staggering 35%, from under 7% pre-pandemic. Contributing to youth disconnection is the ongoing digital divide, the gap between populations that have the technological infrastructure to stay on the grid from home, and those who do not. The latter group is disproportionately composed of people living in poor communities, public housing, and homeless shelters, predominantly impacting Black and Latino New Yorkers. The divide makes remote education and finding a job increasingly difficult during the ongoing shutdown. While de Blasio’s office cited the pandemic as a reason for the report’s further delay, the mayor regularly discusses the city’s major increase in unemployment, and has connected it and other upheaval to the significant rise in gun violence this year. But he has not offered any city solutions to better engage disconnected youth and even cut long-established programs. Youth aging out of foster care are particularly vulnerable to missing out on job and education opportunities, especially during the pandemic when many transition services were upended. “[Education and employment] is certainly an issue in that our membership, the foster care agencies, are considering it very heavily and adding it to decision-making about discharging youth at this point,” said Lisa Gitelson, head of the downstate programs of the Council of Family and Child Caring Agencies. Statewide, 205 young people were discharged to “another planned living arrangement,” or self-responsibility, between January and October, according to data published by the state Office of Children and Family Services. More than half of them, 121, were in New York City. Yet while there are risks involved in discharging youth from foster care, there are also risks in postponing it — ones that play into other, more clinical, public health issues that have gotten greater attention from elected officials. “Many of our foster families, whether they are kinship or non-kinship, are older families and they’re families with co-morbidities that put them at risk,” Gitelson said. “There’s a slew of problems around young people right now that we’re trying to figure out,” Parker told Gotham Gazette, referring to the work of her organization, JobsFirstNYC, which focuses on workforce development. “We’ve never had a crisis like this but whenever we’ve had crises, young people are at the back of the line,” she said. “You always focus on the professionals, getting them back to work, and eventually work your way down to young people. But this time is very different and I think we need different strategies.” Even some of the city’s existing programs to improve the experience of disconnected youth have suffered under the economic contraction, which has led to billions in lost revenue for the city and state. High on that list is the city’s Summer Youth Employment Program, which pre-pandemic connected young people with roughly 75,000 paid job opportunities during the summer months. During budget negotiations this year, the program was scrapped and only reinstated after an outcry from advocates and elected leaders, and then only partially reinstated. The Disconnected Youth Task Force report is supposed to include an assessment of the barriers to work and school employment and map the skills and education employers are seeking. The law also requires the task force to analyze the policies and programs that impact disconnected youth and provide recommendations to the city for improvements. “There’s not a reason for it to have taken this long,” said Parker. “For something to take this long shows that it’s not a priority.”
    *** by Ethan Geringer-Sameth, reporter, Gotham Gazette